The kind of dog treat you use when training your dog can make a big difference in how successful your training sessions are. With so many options available, it can be hard to know what dog treats you should buy.
There is a simple answer to this question. Use whatever training treat your dog enjoys! However, knowing how to "grade" your dog's treats and keeping them varied will benefit you in a few ways:
- You'll be able to train new behaviors faster
- You'll be able to fade out the use of food treats in training more effectively
- Your dog will be more focused on you (and responsive to you) around distractions
- Your dog won't get tired of the the "same-old" treat
- You can better manage your dog's treat calorie intake
Read on for tips to figure out what training treats your dog likes best and when to use different treats to bolster your dog's training.
How to Figure Out What Treats Your Dog Likes
You might hear your dog trainer talk about using "high value" vs. "low value" training treats — this is referring to the value your dog places in each food reward, not the price you pay for the treats at the store. You'll want to figure out what treats your dog finds more valuable than others.
While there are some basic assumptions we make regarding what treats dogs hold in higher esteem, there always seems to be exceptions to the rule. One training client of mine had a dog who much preferred dry and bland treats over smelly freeze-dried liver!
What Are "High Value" Treats?
High value treats tend to be moist or freeze-dried, extra smelly, and something your dog doesn't get very often (if at all) outside of training sessions. Think tiny pieces of chicken, liverwurst, tripe, or even peanut butter (make sure it's xylitol-free) smeared on a spoon. Think of your high value treats as giving your dog an "A+++" for behavior and training.
When Should You Use High Value Treats?
- When first introducing a brand new behavior
- In highly distracting environments, such as a group dog training class
- When rewarding your dog for a quick or high-quality response to a cue
- During important socialization and proactive exposure training for puppies
- If working on counter conditioning as part of a behavior modification plan for leash reactivity, aggression, anxiety, or fear
(Avoid using foods that are high in fat, such as bacon or sausage. You don't want your dog to end up with an upset stomach or pancreatitis.)
What Are "Medium Value" Treats?
These treats are usually semi-moist or dry treats made from ingredients that your dog doesn't get in their regular food. Medium value treats and are given more frequently during training sessions and in everyday routines than high value treats.
When Should You Use Medium Value Treats?
- When maintaining an already learned behavior
- In mildly distracting environments
- Throughout the day for good behavior
- As part of regular enrichment activities
What Are "Low Value" Treats?
Lower value treats are great to work into your training because they tend to be lower calorie than high and medium value dog treats. Low value treats are usually dry and crunchy. Myself and many of my clients use our dog's regular food for this level of treating. Having a low value treat option is important in helping you fade out treats in training.
When Should You Use Low Value Treats?
- If your dog performs a requested and previously generalized cue, but it's a "C" grade performance (this also might indicate that your dog needs to be further from a distraction or might need to go back a few steps in training)
- Throughout the day to encourage continued good behavior
- In low to no distraction training environments
- As part of regular enrichment activities
- When you're working on fading out the use of treats for a specific behavior
Have a Dog Treat "Taste Test"
To help you pick out the training treats that your dog will most enjoy and respond to the best, set up treat taste test for your pup. (Note: Check treat ingredients to ensure they don't contain anything your dog is allergic or sensitive to.)
First, pick out a few different options of treats for them to try, based on:
- Protein type: Have a variety of fish, poultry, beef, pork, or lamb. Include non-meat-based treats, such as peanut butter.
- Texture: Choose different treat options based on their texture type — dry, semi-moist, jerky, freeze-dried, or wet.
- Ease of Delivery: When you're picking out taste test options, make sure you're choosing treats that are easy for you to give your dog. Training treats should be pea-sized or smaller. If the treats are larger than this in the bag, see if you can easily break them up into smaller pieces.
Pro Tip: Many pet supply stores will have samples available upon request of different treats to try. This is how I often discover new brands of treats to mix into my training treat rotation.
Next, give your dog a choice between the different treats. Put one kind of treat in one hand and a different kind in the other hand, and close your hands to make a fist. (You can also use small cups to cover the treat options on the ground if you prefer, especially if your dog gets mouthy when taking treats.)
Allow your dog to sniff both hands, watching to see which they show the most interest in. Give them the one they sniff at, lick at, or paw at the most.
Switch out different treats, rotating in ones you've already tried with different alternatives, to get an idea of what your dog's high value, medium value, and low value treats are.
Dog Trainer's Top Picks for Training Treats
High Value Dog Training Treats
Here's Daisy, one of our office pups, showing how much she loves her high value minnow treats:
Medium Value Dog Training Treats
Low Value Dog Training Treats
PRO TIP: Work your dog's brain! Hold back a portion of your dog's regular meals to use as training treats throughout the day, and feed all of their regular meals from interactive toys and puzzles.
The kind of treats you use when training your dog (or just want to give them a special treat) depend on your dog's personal preferences. And remember, it's not always about food! Many dogs find toys, attention, and other real-life rewards incredibly rewarding too. Knowing what your dog likes and what they'll work for will make your training more effective.
Comment below and tell us what your dog's high, mid, and low value treats are!
- How to Use Treats the Right Way in Dog Training
- Be a Slot Machine: How to Fade Out Food Treats
- How Many Treats Can You Give Your Dog During Training
- Choosing the Best Interactive Toys and Puzzles for Your Dog
- Short and Sweet Training Sessions
- Take Advantage of Daily Dog Training Opportunities
- Keep Your Dog Safe — 6 Important Behaviors to Train